PriMera Scientific Engineering (ISSN: 2834-2550)

Review Article

Volume 4 Issue 4

Unleashing the Tactile Dimension: Exploring VR Technologies for Authentic Calligraphy Training

Nan Ma and Dongxing Yu*

March 28, 2024

DOI : 10.56831/PSEN-04-122


The study explores how Virtual Reality (VR) applications address the challenges of conveying tactile feedback in traditional calligraphy practice. It examines the feasibility of VR in simulating calligraphy's tactile aspects, including brush strokes, ink flow, and paper texture, and the importance of tactile feedback in learning calligraphy. The challenges in simulating realistic tactile sensations in VR are discussed, alongside current technologies in haptic feedback, strategies for simulating calligraphy tools, and case studies of VR calligraphy applications. It concludes with future directions for improving tactile feedback in VR calligraphy training.

Keywords: Virtual Reality; Tactile Feedback; Calligraphy; Haptic Technology; Educational Technology


  1. Acevedo P., et al. “Effects of Tactile Feedback on Conceptual Understanding of Electromagnetism in a Virtual Reality Experience”. 2022 IEEE International Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality Adjunct (ISMAR-Adjunct) (2022): 588-593.
  2. Bark K., et al. “Effects of Vibrotactile Feedback on Human Learning of Arm Motions”. IEEE Transactions on Neural Systems and Rehabilitation Engineering 23 (2015): 51-63.
  3. Berton F., et al. “Crowd Navigation in VR: Exploring Haptic Rendering of Collisions”. IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics 28 (2020): 2589-2601.
  4. Bilal O., et al. “A Flexible Spiraling‐Metasurface as a Versatile Haptic Interface”. Advanced Materials Technologies (2020).
  5. Cheung V, Tang Y and Chan K. “Medical students' perception of the application of a virtual reality training model to acquire vaginal examination skills”. International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics (2023): 827-832.
  6. Clemente F., et al. “Intraneural sensory feedback restores grip force control and motor coordination while using a prosthetic hand”. Journal of Neural Engineering 16.2 (2019).
  7. Danieau F., et al. “Toward Haptic Cinematography: Enhancing Movie Experiences with Camera-Based Haptic Effects”. IEEE MultiMedia 21 (2014): 11-21.
  8. Danieau F., et al. “Enhancing Audiovisual Experience with Haptic Feedback: A Survey on HAV”. IEEE Transactions on Haptics 6 (2013): 193-205.
  9. Ferreira-Brito F., et al. “Virtual Reality for Health and Wellbeing”. Proceedings of the 21st International Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia (2022).
  10. Galofaro E., et al. “Rendering Immersive Haptic Force Feedback via Neuromuscular Electrical Stimulation”. Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) 22.14 (2022).
  11. Geisen M, Fox A and Klatt S. “VR as an Innovative Learning Tool in Sports Education”. Applied Sciences (2023).
  12. Günther S., et al. “Smooth as Steel Wool: Effects of Visual Stimuli on the Haptic Perception of Roughness in Virtual Reality”. Proceedings of the 2022 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (2022).
  13. Guruswamy V, Lang J and Lee W. “IIR Filter Models of Haptic Vibration Textures”. IEEE Transactions on Instrumentation and Measurement 60 (2011): 93-103.
  14. Han P., et al. “Waving Blanket: Dynamic Liquid Distribution for Multiple Tactile Feedback using Rewirable Piping System”. ACM SIGGRAPH 2022 Emerging Technologies (2022).
  15. Ilhan R and Ali F. “Developing a Guided Tactile Feedback System for Visually Impaired People”. European Journal of Science and Technology (2023).
  16. Jones M., et al. “Visualizing Without Vision at the Microscale: Students with Visual Impairments Explore Cells with Touch”. Journal of Science Education and Technology 15 (2006): 345-351.
  17. Kamboh U., et al. “Virtual Reality in Neurosurgery- A Neurostimulator – Based Postgraduate Residency Training: A Novel Step Towards Skillful Young Neurosurgeons”. Pakistan Journal of Neurological Surgery (2022).
  18. Kirby M and D’Angiulli A. “From Inclusion to Creativity Through Haptic Drawing: Unleashing the "Untouched" in Educational Contexts”. The Open Education Journal 4 (2011): 67-79.
  19. Komura H and Ohka M. “Edge angle perception precision of active and passive touches for haptic VR using dot-matrix display”. Journal of Advanced Mechanical Design, Systems, and Manufacturing (2019).
  20. Ledwos N., et al. “Assessment of learning curves on a simulated neurosurgical task using metrics selected by artificial intelligence”. Journal of neurosurgery (2022): 1-12.
  21. Lee J., et al. “Stretchable Skin‐Like Cooling/Heating Device for Reconstruction of Artificial Thermal Sensation in Virtual Reality”. Advanced Functional Materials (2020).
  22. Li F., et al. “Soft Robotic Glove with Sensing and Force Feedback for Rehabilitation in Virtual Reality”. Biomimetics 8.1 (2023).
  23. Liu Y., et al. “Skin-Integrated Haptic Interfaces Enabled by Scalable Mechanical Actuators for Virtual Reality”. IEEE Internet of Things Journal 10 (2023): 653-663.
  24. Lucaci A., et al. Influence of Texture Fidelity on Spatial Perception in Virtual Reality (2022): 244-251.
  25. Ma N and Yu D. “Application of Virtual Reality Technology in the Exhibition System of Clothing Museum”. In 2022 10th International Conference on Orange Technology (ICOT). IEEE (2022): 1-4.
  26. Marchesotti S., et al. “Neural signatures of visuo-motor integration during human-robot interactions”. Frontiers in Neurorobotics 16 (2023).
  27. Michikawa R, Endo T and Matsuno F. “A Multi-DoF Exoskeleton Haptic Device for the Grasping of a Compliant Object Adapting to a User's Motion Using Jamming Transitions”. IEEE Transactions on Robotics 39 (2023): 373-385.
  28. Minogue J., et al. “The impact of haptic augmentation on middle school students’ conceptions of the animal cell”. Virtual Reality 10 (2006): 293-305.
  29. Moody L., et al. “Beyond the visuals: tactile augmentation and sensory enhancement in an arthroscopy simulator”. Virtual Reality 13 (2009): 59-68.
  30. Mystakidis S., et al. “Design, Development, and Evaluation of a Virtual Reality Serious Game for School Fire Preparedness Training”. Education Sciences (2022).
  31. Nataraj R., et al. “Disproportionate positive feedback facilitates sense of agency and performance for a reaching movement task with a virtual hand”. PLoS ONE 15.5 (2020).
  32. Nishino H., et al. “A Japanese Calligraphy Trainer Based on Skill Acquisition Through Haptization”. 2010 24th IEEE International Conference on Advanced Information Networking and Applications (2010): 1225-1232.
  33. Nishino H., et al. “A calligraphy training system based on skill acquisition through haptization”. Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 2 (2011): 271-284.
  34. Oh J., et al. “A Liquid Metal Based Multimodal Sensor and Haptic Feedback Device for Thermal and Tactile Sensation Generation in Virtual Reality”. Advanced Functional Materials (2020).
  35. Pamungkas D and Ward K. “Electro-tactile feedback system to enhance virtual reality experience”. International Journal of Computer Theory and Engineering 8 (2016): 465-470.
  36. Pantelios M., et al. “Haptics technology in Educational Applications, a Case Study”. J. Digit. Inf. Manag 2 (2004): 171-178.
  37. Pardini S., et al. “The Role of Personalization in the User Experience, Preferences and Engagement with Virtual Reality Environments for Relaxation”. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19.12 (2022).
  38. Patel K, Jarosz K and Özel T. “Physics-Based Simulations of Chip Flow over Micro-Textured Cutting Tool in Orthogonal Cutting of Alloy Steel”. Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing (2021).
  39. Pezent E., et al. “Design, Control, and Psychophysics of Tasbi: A Force-Controlled Multimodal Haptic Bracelet”. IEEE Transactions on Robotics 38 (2022): 2962-2978.
  40. Ramic-Brkic B., et al. “Developing a Virtual Reality (VR) Lab for Improving the Safety of Pyrotechnicians”. 2022 International Balkan Conference on Communications and Networking (BalkanCom) (2022): 195-199.
  41. Rangarajan K, Davis H and Pucher P. “Systematic Review of Virtual Haptics in Surgical Simulation: A Valid Educational Tool?”. Journal of surgical education (2020).
  42. Rey B., et al. “Development and Testing of a Portable Virtual Reality-Based Mirror Visual Feedback System with Behavioral Measures Monitoring”. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 19.4 (2022).
  43. Rosa N., et al. “The Influence of Visual Cues on Passive Tactile Sensations in a Multimodal Immersive Virtual Environment”. Proceedings of the 2015 ACM on International Conference on Multimodal Interaction (2015).
  44. Ryan G., et al. “Virtual reality learning: A randomized controlled trial assessing medical student knowledge of fetal development”. International journal of gynaecology and obstetrics: the official organ of the International Federation of Gynaecology and Obstetrics (2023).
  45. Ryu J and Kim G. Using a vibro-tactile display for enhanced collision perception and presence (2004): 89-96.
  46. Schiefer M., et al. “Sensory feedback by peripheral nerve stimulation improves task performance in individuals with upper limb loss using a myoelectric prosthesis”. Journal of Neural Engineering 13.1 (2016).
  47. Schmidt G., et al. “Printed Multilayer Piezoelectric Transducers on Paper for Haptic Feedback and Dual Touch-Sound Sensation”. Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) 22.10 (2022).
  48. Seritan S., et al. “InteraChem: Virtual Reality Visualizer for Reactive Interactive Molecular Dynamics”. Journal of Chemical Education (2021).
  49. Valluripally S., et al. “Modeling and Defense of Social Virtual Reality Attacks Inducing Cybersickness”. IEEE Transactions on Dependable and Secure Computing 19 (2022): 4127-4144.
  50. Vargas L., et al. “Object Shape and Surface Topology Recognition Using Tactile Feedback Evoked through Transcutaneous Nerve Stimulation”. IEEE Transactions on Haptics 13 (2020): 152-158.
  51. Wang C., et al. “Application of VR technology in civil engineering education”. Computer Applications in Engineering Education 30 (2021): 335 348.
  52. Wang X., et al. “VibroWeight: Simulating Weight and Center of Gravity Changes of Objects in Virtual Reality for Enhanced Realism”. 2022 IEEEm Hapticsm Symposium (HAPTICS) (2022): 1-7.
  53. Wegen M., et al. “An Overview of Wearable Haptic Technologies and Their Performancem in Virtual Object Exploration”. Sensors (Basel, Switzerland) 23.3 (2023).
  54. Yang T., et al. “Recent Advances and Opportunities of Active Materials for Haptic Technologies in Virtual and Augmented Reality”. Advanced Functional Materials (2021): 31.
  55. Zhao J., et al. “Smart City Construction and Rendering Based on Virtual City Space”. 2020 International Conference on Virtual Reality and Visualization (ICVRV) (2020): 276-277.
  56. Zheng J., et al. “Cognitive and motor cortex activation during robot-assisted multi-sensory interactive motor rehabilitation training: An fNIRS based pilot study”. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 17 (2023).
  57. Zuki F., et al. “Gamification, sensory feedback, adaptive function on virtual reality rehabilitation: a brief review”. 2022 International Conference on Digital Transformation and Intelligence (ICDI) (2022): 330-335.